Electronic Arts often can be considered the king of sports games. It’s certainly got a lock on football.
When it comes to basketball, however, 2K Sports unquestionably has had the better games.
That trend continues this year, with “NBA 2K8” defeating “NBA Live 08.”


Both games are improvements over their 2006 predecessors, but neither breaks a lot of new ground. Personally, I think sports games should be released every other year so that there would be time for substantial changes. But that’s probably just me.

Find more videos like this on Streetball.com - Basketball and Hip-Hop Lifestyle
As far as textures and overall looks, I like “NBA Live 08” better. Its menus are cleaner and actually make sense — as opposed to “NBA 2K8,” which has struggled for years to make a menu that’s easy to follow.
“NBA Live 08” also jumps straight into a practice mode upon loading, which I like a lot. And during loading screens, it asks trivia questions — at which I fail horribly, but I still like the idea.
On the other hand, the player animations in “NBA 2K8” are smoother and more realistic, and players running into the sidelines actually get a response. Those people standing on the sidelines aren’t just wooden props anymore, which is cool.


“NBA 2K8” also adds in neat signature style animations, allowing the players to perform moves that you would see in real life.
“NBA Live 08” kind of has something similar in that the superstars have special moves, but they don’t look as cool as in “2K8.”
One nice thing in “NBA Live” is a floor overlay that pops up when you hold in the left bumper button. It shows you the hot spots for the player you’re controlling — red for where they’re strongest, blue for weakest. This is especially helpful for someone like me who will recognize names of players but not really know where they’re strongest in play.
Meanwhile, “NBA 2K8” has its own useful tool, a guide that pops up to tell you how a certain play should be pulled off, where a player needs to be, where the ball should go, etc. It’s a nice way to learn the different plays.
“NBA Live” doesn’t have much new in the way of game modes, continuing with standards such as dynasty mode, slam-dunk contest, three-point shootout and a rookie challenge. European leagues have been added, as has the ability to put together a team of whatever players you want. Neither of those has a major impact, however.
“NBA 2K8” also only has minor additions. It changes the name of its streetball mode from 24/7 to NBA Blacktop and takes out the pointless attempt at a story. Association mode is still strong, but it’s largely unchanged other than some interesting personality/morale factors.
So, given all this, why is “NBA 2K8” such a clear winner? It’s in the gameplay. The controls are more responsive in “NBA Live 08” than they were last year, but the game just plays better in “NBA 2K8.” And while each game has similar modes, “NBA 2K8” manages to make its more fun.
Strangely, both games have issues with players missing easy shots. I’m not sure why this is a problem, but it happens frequently in both games, and that’s frustrating.
The artificial intelligence also is better in “NBA 2K8” than in “NBA Live.” “Live’s” AI is improved over last year’s, but I still found many instances, especially on defense, in which players would leave opponents wide open for shots. And I’m pretty sure they weren’t informed about rebounds.
“NBA 2K8,” meanwhile, has some pretty tough AI. And I don’t mean tough in that “the computer is cheating” way. The players are smart and will walk all over you if you let them (and believe me, I did, frequently, because I’m not particularly good at basketball games).
The 2K games have long been the winner online and this year is no exception. The online play is stable and mostly without lag, and just about any option you can think of is there. Players can participate in quick games, or they can go as far as playing in tournaments, seasons, NBA Blacktop games, even drafts. And of course, there are stats and leaderboards galore.
“NBA Live” comes a little closer this year with the addition of online leagues but it still isn’t nearly as in-depth as “NBA 2K8.”
Comparing these games is helpful for people who can afford only one game, and in that case “NBA 2K8” is the one to pick up. But “NBA Live 08” is not a bad game by any means and it certainly has improved over last year. If that’s the one you end up with (say, as a Christmas gift), it’s not the end of the world.
Both games continue to have little issues that could be fixed (I particularly wish for a revamped menu in the 2K games), but either one would be entertaining for a basketball fan.
Tags: Gamers, NBA, Streetball by DotGuap
No Comments »